Virtual Oases
Inviting Girls to Pinewood Derby
By Jessawhy
It was with great reservation that I said yes to the calling of Cub Scout committee chair last November. My oldest son is six, not old enough to be a wolf, and my only experience with cub scouts was more than five years ago as a Bear Den assistant.
Although I think the scouting program has helped many boys for generations, I object to it being part of the LDS church. First, not all boys enjoy scouting. Second, girls don’t get to participate, and programs that are supposedly comparable, really aren’t. Perhaps these objections are mutually exclusive, nonetheless, they are two reasons why I didn’t want to accept the calling. Still, I’ve never turned a calling down and with my husband’s encouragement I accepted, hoping to do my best to help both the boys and girls ages 8-11 in my ward.
So, when a woman at Roundtable (the scouting training/ idea forum) suggested packs invite the Activity Days girls in the upcoming Pinewood Derby, I jumped at the chance to include the girls in this exciting racing event. My visiting teacher happens to be the leader of the Activity Days girls and also the wife of the first counselor in our new bishopric. When I told her about my plans to invite the girls to participate, she was excited and made plans to go buy the girls their own cars to make and race. Actually, I told a lot of women in the ward, including the bishop’s wife and they were all excited. The only woman who disliked the idea was one of my new den leaders, who is not a mother of a cub scout. While I listened to her concerns, I figured it was my decision to make, and the benefits (equality, learning, and mutual respect) far outweighed the costs (the boys may not like the girls there).
Apparently I was wrong. The first counselor in our bishopric approached me on Wednesday night during a youth activity at the church to discuss cub scouting details. We talked about callings that needed to be filled, the possibility of combining our packs with another ward, and the scheduling of the Pinewood Derby. I was confused about whether the stake was having a combined Derby, or if the wards were having their own. When I mentioned it, the counselor said off-hand. “Oh, we’re not doing that.” Still confused, I asked for clarification. “We’re not inviting the girls. It’s the Bishop’s call.” He quickly walked away.
I was very upset with the way he addressed the issue, by not explaining why the decision was not mine to make, or why it was reversed.
The more I thought about it, the more I saw the irony of the situation, and I felt both disappointed and angry.
The way I was treated was a symptom of the greater problem of the way women are viewed in the church. That’s the exact problem I was trying to address by inviting the girls to the Pinewood Derby in the first place.
Despite this situation, I really like our new Bishop. He’s been a good friend for the five years we’ve been in this ward. He’s one of the most humble and open-minded men I know. My admiration for him was one of the reasons I was most disappointed with this incident.
I hope to speak with him this week and discuss this situation. I’m prepared to explain what happened and justify my decision to invite the girls, not only based on the idea of equality, but based on the way Jesus treated women in his day, far better than the rest of society.
Currently, I’m struggling to address the situation in a way that is both humble, and assertive. Being inexperienced in Cub Scouts, I know I need to defer to those who know the ropes. However, I’m not compelled by an argument based on tradition.
In Strangers in Paradox, the Tuscano’s give this little gem regarding tradition, “An objection based on tradition in a church that accepts continuing revelation is hardly an objection at all.”
Regardless of how the conversation goes, I am looking forward to discussing the issues of gender equality in church with a friendly church leader.
I hope that he will be open to my experience and be able to see my perspective, while at the same time, I hope that I will be able to listen and understand his perspective as Bishop.
Joseph Smith Lesson 20: A Heart Full of Love and Faith
(1) From the life of Joseph Smith
Joseph Smith’s life and experiences must have been profoundly disruptive to his family life. In terms of predictability, security, and financial and social stability, his family circumstances were anything but ideal.
(1) In the church we have ideals about how families should be—parents married in the temple, father working, mother at home full time, both parents active, committed members of the church, and a house full of happy, well-adjusted, obedient children. But many—maybe most—of us aren’t living this life, due to singleness, divorce, widowhood, spousal inactivity, infertility, health problems, unemployment, or other financial difficulties.
How can we develop healthy (not self-punishing) relationships to gospel ideals? How can we focus on the things we can control, such as healthy relationships, love, and respect, rather than on circumstances beyond our control, such as health problems, unemployment, divorce, or military deployment?
(2) How can be build and maintain family routines and traditions even in the face of disruptions such as job loss, separation, military deployment, or divorce? How can we make our homes places of refuge, safety, and solace for children, and for ourselves, even in the face of such uncertainties?
(3) What can we do to strengthen and unite our families when we face disruptions such as job loss, long-term unemployment, long separations due to work or military deployment, or divorce? What have you found helpful in preparing for and facing such challenges?
(4) Joseph Smith was often separated from his children for long periods of time. How can we help husbands and fathers, or wives and mothers, who are living away from home maintain relationships with their spouses and children? How can we help children whose fathers or mothers are physically distant maintain relationships with their parents?
(5) How can we support extended family members, friends, or ward members undergoing financial uncertainty, unemployment, long-term separation, or divorce? If you have undergone such challenges, what kinds of assistance did you find most helpful?
(6) In the church we place a lot of emphasis on family relationships. But people who don’t have immediate family relationships, who don’t have spouses or children, face the same setbacks and challenges (unemployment, health problems, military deployment), and often face them largely alone. How can we include and support people who aren’t living in traditional families? (more…)
Read Full Post | Make a Comment ( 15 so far )Virtual Oases: October 5
- Our favorite YW blog has a great review of Pres. Dalton’s talk today — love the shout-out to the outdoor meeting. Let’s hope that takes. There’s also a lively discussion about it at FMH.
- A moving essay from the latest Sunston: How the Prayers Ran Dry
- Changing diapers while the Dow falls.
- Jana . . . I was just telling my juniors about “Author’s Ridge at the Concord cemetary, how every October I would take a book of poetry and sit near Hawthorne, Emerson, Thoreau, and Alcott. I even got a little teary. So glad you could make it there for me . . .
- Kiskilili takes another look at the tricky word “preside” — can’t we just say father’s are vital?
- Dalene: In praise of parenting teenagers
Just Because:
- P.J. O’Rourke looks at death . . . and makes us laugh
- The feel good story of the year . . . even if you aren’t a Red Sox fan
- Winner of the worst opening sentence contest
Virtual Oases, August 10
- The bittersweet history of the first all-women city council in the United States.
- A poetic tribute to the family garden
- A religion that is part Mormon, part Corpse-Bride, part delightfully precocious pre-teen.
- More amazing historical nuggets from Kylie: Heard of Yesharah?
- BU religion professor Donna Freitas (and her LDS student Heidi Harris) on sex, colleges, and BYU
- Mormons Olympians, including weight lifter Melanie Roach
- Report on the What Women Know session at Sunstone (scroll down in comments for the reports from women who were actually there).
Just because
- “Jesus kept his word,” freed hostage Ingrid Betancourt
- The Healing Touch: Just beautiful. May I be such a devoted companion . . . .
- Feeling a need for more female spiritual exemplars? Take a look at this list.
Virtual Oases, August 3
- Another interfaith marriage personal narrative.
- Oy! I’m exhausted just reading this — but I think Ana’s twin was sitting near me at church. G’bless!
- G: Letting the name go . . .
- Heidi: “This time there will be no angel . . . “
- Justine: I’ll take your surgery and raise you a chronic illness . . . . competition run amok (and hugs to Justine — she’s had a heckuva summer)
- Fun with Arabic at BYU! (hat-tip BCC)
- He wins for most crazy-diligent home teacher! Wow.
- Prayer of the Week
- Post of the Week: Kyle and T&S comparing 19th century funeral sermons (by men) and death poetry (by women, published in Exponent). Fascinating stuff.
Virtual Oases, July 22
- Kristine: What should we call each other at church?
- FMHLisa: Caring for the body, caring for the soul.
- What I’m making for dinner tomorrow night (yeah for gluten-free!)
- A modern-day second wife (not an FLDS story)
- Kathy Soper in the news
- Learning about prayer from the monks
Just because:
- “Woman, why weepest thou?” Today is Mary Magdalene’s feast day.
–By Deborah
Read Full Post | Make a Comment ( 3 so far )Virtual Oases: July 1
- When a woman becomes a family man — quite literally (fascinating slice of culture)
- Justine: Blessings. Like breathing in and out.
- Jana: “When bad things happen to bad people” . . . is God involved?
- News article on the Affirmation meeting with church general authorities
- Not your every day conversion story
- Mormon Momma: Death-wish for Scouts vs. Excited 8-year-old son
- When you loop in single-sex schools as being, ultimately, not beneficial to the cause of women, you lose me — but it’s an interesting discussion nonetheless.
Virtual Oases, June 24
- Margaret: Dying of a broken heart
- From the fabulous historian Ardis: Meet the Singing Mothers
- Allison at Mormon Momma shares the difficulty of her first temple experience to help other sisters who are contemplating attending for the first time.
- Cynthia strikes a similar theme: Stuff I Learned from my First Trip to the Temple
- Tracy M: Smoke and Mirrors
- Mormons really really really believe in heaven — and other fascinating graphs!
- FYI: LDS church letter about gay marriage in California; to be read this Sunday in CA services
- Mormon women and plastic surgery (Frankly, I’d feel more comfortable about plastic surgery if I could link to an article about Mormon men [or any men] and plastic surgery; I find the sheer prevalance of women going under the knife deeply, deeply unsettling.)
- I love posts where the beauty is simply in the honesty. Here is a mom reflecting on her daughter’s Down Syndrome.
Virtual Oases, June 10
- What book would you recommend to new moms?
- Underwear during sacrament meeting and other adventures in parenting . . .
- Image of the week
- Ardis critiques a fascinating article from the archives: “The Mormon Concept of Mother in Heaven: A Sociological Account of Its Origins and Development”
- Segullah: A bi-cultural faith journey — the conclusion.
- G: A good rant about suburban tract housing
- Kiskilili: The phrase “the priesthood band” leaves out a key constituency
Just because:
Read Full Post | Make a Comment ( 1 so far )Virtual Oases, May 20
By Deborah
“You are a poet”: A cool experience with a fabulous foremother
Jen: “The day I lost my dad and found my life
Molly Bennion finds “Manna in the RS/PH manual”
Artemis tries to keep capture our interest with a “sexy topic”
I should have linked to this last month — BiV’s history of Mormon Feminist Blogging
Also a couple of weeks late — another great Mother’s Day talk (hat tip Ana)
And thanks for the shout-out from MormonTimes — a relatively new feature from the Deseret News.
Read Full Post | Make a Comment ( Comments Off on Virtual Oases, May 20 )« Previous Entries